Most contractors either ignore their reviews entirely or respond to negative ones in a way that makes things worse. Both are mistakes. How you respond to reviews, positive and negative, is one of the most visible signals of professionalism that potential customers see.
This guide covers exactly what to say, when to say it, and what to avoid.
When a homeowner reads a negative review, they are not just reading the complaint. They are watching how you handled it. A contractor who responds to a 1-star review with professionalism and an offer to make it right often comes across better than a competitor with no negative reviews at all.
Research on local service businesses consistently shows that 89% of homeowners read business responses to reviews before making a contact decision. Your response is public marketing, directed at the reviewer, but read by everyone who finds your profile.
Most contractors skip this entirely. That is a missed opportunity. A response to a positive review takes 30 seconds and does several things at once: it shows the reviewer their feedback was noticed, it shows future customers that you are engaged, and it gives you a chance to reinforce what made the job go well.
Keep it short and specific. Reference something from the review: the job type, the problem solved, the customer's name if they used it. A generic “Thanks for the review!” is better than nothing, but a specific acknowledgement is significantly better.
Example: “Thanks Sarah, the boiler replacement on that one was a tricky job and we're glad it's running well. Appreciate you taking the time to share your experience.”
Negative reviews are where most contractors damage their reputation further. The instinct to defend, correct the record, or explain what really happened usually backfires. Follow these four rules and you will avoid the most common mistakes.
1. Respond within 48 hours. A negative review that sits unanswered for two weeks signals you either do not care or did not see it. Both are bad. Set up notifications and treat review responses as a business priority.
2. Never argue publicly. Even if the reviewer is completely wrong, a public argument makes you look worse than the original review. Other customers watching cannot verify who is telling the truth, but they can see how you handle conflict.
3. Acknowledge, then move offline. The goal of your response is not to resolve the dispute publicly. It is to show that you take complaints seriously and want to fix them. Acknowledge the experience, apologise for any frustration, and invite them to contact you directly to resolve it.
4. Never repeat the negative claim. If the reviewer says “they left my bathroom flooded,” do not write “we understand you feel we left your bathroom flooded.” Repeating the accusation embeds it. Keep your response focused on resolution, not the complaint.
This structure works for almost any negative review:
“Hi [Name], thank you for sharing your experience. This is not the standard we hold ourselves to and we're sorry it fell short. We'd like to understand what happened and make it right. Please reach out to us directly at [phone/email] and we'll prioritise getting this resolved.”
This response acknowledges the complaint without conceding fault on specific details, shows accountability, and moves the conversation offline. It takes 45 seconds to write and makes you look significantly more professional than no response or a defensive one.
Fake reviews and reviews from people who never hired you do happen. The response strategy is the same. Do not argue publicly. Instead: “Hi, we want to make sure every customer is satisfied, but we don't have a record of working with you. If you've been in touch with us under a different name or contact, please reach out directly at [contact] and we'll look into this straight away.”
This response signals to other readers that the review may not be genuine without making an accusation. It is professional and creates reasonable doubt without confrontation.
Aim to respond to every review, positive and negative. For a business getting 5-10 new reviews per month this is a realistic goal. At higher volumes, prioritise negative reviews and aim for a response on at least 50% of positive ones.
Consistency matters more than length. Short, genuine responses read better than long, templated ones. If a response sounds like it was written by a marketing department, it will be read that way.
Respond to reviews from one dashboard.
ServiceScore surfaces all your verified reviews in one place so you can respond quickly, spot patterns, and never miss a complaint that needs attention.
Start collecting verified reviews free